V for Vendetta Directed by: James McTeigue Written by: Andy & Larry Wachowski (screenplay), Alan Moore (graphic novel) Starring: Natalie Portman, Hugo Weaving, John Hurt, and Stephen Rea
You can’t blame Alan Moore for not wanting his name put on adaptations of his graphic novels. It all began with the atrocious adaptation of The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, and the tradition carried on with the below-average take on his most renowned work, Watchmen. In between those two garbage heaps though, one of his graphic novels was given justice. That movie was V for Vendetta (300 was just pretty.)
Though the Wachowski Brothers switch the focus of the novel to represent restrained rebellion against government rather than all-out anarchy, the movie still moves along with a purposeful pace and terrific action sequences. Moore was still outraged at their nerve, and again, you can’t really blame him. Unlike the other adaptations though, this one was made with more than a cash-in in mind.
Watchmen Directed by: Zack Snyder Written by: David Hayter & Alex Zse (screenplay), Alan Moore (graphic novel) Starring: Jackie Earle Haley, Patrick Wilson, Malin Ackerman, and Billy Crudup
You must give credit where credit is due: Zack Snyder knows which graphic novels to adapt to the screen. 300 was his claim to highly stylized fame, and now with Watchmen, he tackles perhaps the most important graphic novel of all time. Of course it won’t live up to the source material, even when/especially because he sticks to it almost frame for frame.
Why storyboard when it’s already been done for you? This appears to be the only original question Snyder poses. His source material must do all the talking, because he is concerned with stylistic bloodshed by the gallons. As he did in 300, he lets his characters run rampant within the frame, leaving nothing- violent or sexual -to the imagination.